Resolute Square

It’s Trump vs.…. YOU

David Pepper says that fundamentally, the election is about Trump vs. YOU, and YOUR freedom. "What freedoms are we individually and collectively willing to lose if Trump wins?"
Published:March 21, 2024
Share

*Read all of David's writing and watch his fantastic videos at Pepperspectives!

By David Pepper

One of the best parts about traveling the nation is how many insights others share with me everywhere I go.

So many good ideas. So many best practices. So many fresh observations. Together, these conversations fuel so much of my own thinking and energy to keep pushing forward.

Along those lines, two weeks ago in Florida, my host, Bob Gary (also an Ohioan), told me he wanted to send me a list he had been working on.

“A list of what?” I asked.

“The freedoms we will lose if Trump becomes President,” he said. “All Americans should ask themselves, ‘which freedoms from this list am I willing to give up?’

To which I immediately responded: “That’s brilliant…Send me the list.”

And over night, he sent one very scary and long list.

The next morning, I woke up, read Bob’s list, and he and I talked for a good hour before the luncheon where I gave remarks.

And the conclusion I came to as I reviewed his list and over that hour was what I present in the video above.

First, that not only is Bob’s question the right question — what freedoms are we individually and collectively willing to lose if Trump wins?

(My defiant answer is: NONE).

But second, the question Bob asks actually re-frames the entire Presidential election in a crucial way.

Yes, 2024 pits Trump vs. Biden. Those are the two opponents facing off. And many of us believe Biden has a lot to offer as he vies for a second term.

But more fundamentally, the election is about Trump vs. YOU, and YOUR freedom. And all the freedoms you/we will lose if he wins.

It’s that stark, as Trump made even more clear Saturday in Ohio with his unhinged and violent rhetoric.

And as Bob suggested by putting together a long list (I put together my own shortened version above), Trump has made painfully clear—through such increasingly disturbing words, through his past actions, and that his allies have put together in their ominous 2025 plan (more on it here)—just how many basic freedoms and fundamental American principles he would eviscerate as President.

So…the next time someone says to you they’re not sure what to do in the election because they’re not sold on Joe Biden, remind them:

This election is fundamentally about Trump vs. THEM (tell them, “YOU”), and their/“YOUR” FREEDOM;

And when they ask you what you mean, walk through all the freedoms they risk losing under a second Trump term (make your own list, just like Bob and I did);

Then ask them, as Bob does, which of those freedoms they’re willing to lose.

For most people, that question will answer itself.

(Thank you, Bob, for sharing your list).

Related

  • "Governing by rally and chaos" - A look ahead In 2025
    That Trippi Show

    That Trippi Show

    In the last show of 2024, Joe and Alex discuss a possible war with... checks notes... Greenland? Panama? It's just another day in the world of Trump. Why Joe thinks it's all governing by rally - and why it shows that the Trump coalition is still more fragile than many understand. Is Joe Manchin right? Is the Democratic brand toxic? Finally: What are Joe and Alex's bold predictions for 2025 and 2026 (and beyond?) Happy New Year everyone - see you in 2025!
    January 2, 2025
  • The Imperial Presidency
    The Lincoln Project Podcast

    The Lincoln Project Podcast

    Timothy Naftali, presidential historian for the Nixon Presidential Library, Columbia Scholar, and prolific writer/author, sits down with host Rick Wilson to discuss the possibility of an imperial presidency and what that means for the US on the world stage. Follow Timothy Naftali on X at @TimNaftali and read the article Rick mentions in this episode here: https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2021/01/trump-worst-president-history/617730/ Follow Rick Wilson at @TheRickWilson on X or at https://bsky.app/profile/therickwilson.bsky.social at Bluesky, and subscribe to his Substack at therickwilson.substack.com. Join the fight with Lincoln Project at www.lincolnproject.us and follow us on X at @ProjectLincoln.
    January 2, 2025
  • How Did Trump Win?
    Amee Vanderpool writes, "This question seems to bounce within an echo chamber in the media and no one has been able to catch it, or really attempt to answer it, so I'm looking for clues."
    December 16, 2024
  • The Perception Election

    Punching Up with Maya May

    Yeah, hate and Donald Trump won. Hope and Kamala Harris lost, but that's not the end of America's story. It’s time to get to work earning the hearts, heads and trust of Gen Z by talking to them now - not just before the next election. The good news? It was a perception election we have the power to shift those perceptions. Maya's guest Victor Shi has a lot of good news and hope that you won't want to miss!
    December 12, 2024
  • Q+A with Rick Wilson
    The Lincoln Project Podcast

    The Lincoln Project Podcast

    Debuting a new installment of the LP podcast, Rick reads and answers mail from our devoted LP audience. If you'd like Rick to answer your burning question, please email it to podcast@lincolnproject.us for future Q+A episodes. Follow Rick Wilson at @TheRickWilson on X and all the other social media platforms, and subscribe to his Substack at therickwilson.substack.com. Join the fight with Lincoln Project at www.lincolnproject.us and follow us on X at @ProjectLincoln. And please subscribe, rate and review this podcast, thank you!
    December 10, 2024