Resolute Square

For Trump, Success Is Retribution

Al From writes, "I never want a president — even Trump — to fail. But I don’t want a president to fail the country, either. "
Published:December 12, 2024
Share

By Al From

President Trump said on Meet the Press that success will be his retribution. That’s the problem.

I never want a president — even Trump — to fail. But I don’t want a president to fail the country, either.  

They are not the same — especially with Trump. If Trump does well by the country, that’s one thing. But if he succeeds in much of what he says he wants to do, he’ll fail the country — and that is quite another. 

To be absolutely clear, if he succeeds in reducing grocery prices and bringing order to the border, that’s good.

But if he succeeds in seeking retribution against his political enemies or really does try to put Liz Cheney, Bennie Thompson, and the members of the January 6th Committee in jail — where he said they belonged on Meet the Press — he will have failed the country and undermined our democracy.

If he succeeds in putting in place a director of the FBI who has called for prosecution (persecution) of a 60-person enemies list who he calls members of the deep state, Trump will have failed the country and undermined the rule of law.

If he succeeds with his appointment of a grossly unqualified and morally challenged secretary of defense, Trump will have failed our country and undermined our national security.

If he succeeds in putting in place a director of national intelligence who spouts Kremlin talking points and supports deposed Syrian dictator Bashar al-Assad, a DNI who would likely not get a security clearance, Trump will have failed the country and undermined our ability to gather vital intelligence in cooperation with our allies.

And, if he succeeds with his appointment of an anti-vaxxer, science-denying Secretary of Health and Human Services, Trump will have failed the country and endangered our public health.

Trump has told us what he wants. He has made all of those outrageously unqualified appointments. 

Only Senate Republicans can stop him — by exercising the advice and consent power granted them in the Constitution. Democrats will be in the minority in the Senate. Because they unwisely gave up the filibuster on Cabinet officials a decade ago, they cannot block Trump’s appointments without Republican votes.

There’s no doubt a significant number of Senate Republicans are very uneasy about having to vote to confirm candidates they know are unqualified and potentially dangerous for sensitive positions. But they know that Trump and his MAGA allies will make their lives miserable — to the point of running a primary opponent against them in their next election — if they don’t roll over and support his nominees. 

So far, despite the discomfort they’re undoubtedly feeling, no Senate Republicans have said publicly that they will vote against even one of the Trump appointments. Not one. So far, no profiles in courage in the GOP Caucus. 

With confirmation hearings about to begin and so much at stake, we can only hope that will change.    
 
Al From is the founder of the Democratic Leadership Council and the author of The New Democrats and Return to Power. He does regular commentary in The Spy Newspapers and The Political Whisperers.

Related

  • The REAL State of the Union, Part 1
    That Trippi Show

    That Trippi Show

    If you skipped Trump's "State of the Union" record-setting ramble, this show's for you. Joe and Alex dive in - what actually is the state of our union? Part 1 of where we see the world, the economy, and the state of both parties... Starting with how Joe thinks Trump's second term has completely remade American foreign policy. It's Trump and Putin against the world. He answers maybe the scariest listener question to date. And what about here at home? Turns out, when you burn it all down... it takes a REALLY long time for things to grow back.
    March 7, 2025
  • The POTUS Who Cried Mandate

    Punching Up with Maya May

    Trump has no mandate. Full stop. Does he want to pretend he does? You bet! But it’s a bad bet for Trump and he is way overplaying a bad hand. His sinking numbers with the American people on everything from the economy to Elon tell the story. Lisa Senecal, executive editor of Resolute Square, joins Maya May to punch up at a very deserving bully, Donald John Trump, the POTUS Who Cried Mandate. They discuss why Trump’s attempt to show strength in Tuesday's Castro-esque rant before the joint session of Congress was really a huge tell of where he knows he’s weak and failing.
    March 6, 2025
  • The Collapse of Justice and the Rise of Executive Power
    The Enemies List

    Rick Wilson's The Enemies List

    The balance of power in American democracy is being tested like never before. In this episode Rick is joined by legal expert and author Tristan Snell to discuss the latest legal battles surrounding Trump, the Supreme Court’s role in shaping executive power, and the broader implications for American democracy. They break down key cases, including the limits of presidential immunity, the Administrative Procedure Act, and the growing constitutional crisis if Trump defies court rulings. Visit Tristan's Substack at tristansnell.com.
    March 5, 2025
  • Ian Bremmer on Why We're F****d
    The Lincoln Project Podcast

    The Lincoln Project Podcast

    Political scientist, author, and entrepreneur Ian Bremmer -- who's also the founder and president of Eurasia Group and the founder of GZERO Media -- stops by to chat with Rick about how we're fucked, and why we're fucked. There is nothing like sitting down with a good ole expert friend at the beginning of a potential World War to discuss the American economy, AI, global politics, and the growing dangers inside and outside the U.S. democratic government. ・・・・・・・・・・・・・・ Follow Ian Bremmer at @ianbremmer on X & @ianbremmer.com on Bluesky Check out more of Ian's work at @eurasiagroup.net and @gzeromedia.com
    March 4, 2025
  • February 28, 2025: The Day America Publicly Embraced Tyranny
    Brian Daitzman writes, "For years, U.S. allies privately acknowledged what had been taboo to say outright: that the United States, under Trump, was falling into autocracy and was no longer a defender of democracy, but an enemy of it." Now, it's all out in public.
    March 3, 2025